Showing posts with label MT WHITE. Show all posts
Showing posts with label MT WHITE. Show all posts

Wednesday, September 28, 2022

MT White The Artist’s Fortitude Fame pt II

MT White
The Artist’s Fortitude
Fame pt II



David Lynch was well-known enough before 1990 but that’s the year his fame peaked with Twin Peaks on television, Wild at Heart in theaters and his directing the commercials for the campaign promoting Michael Jackson’s Dangerous album.

But Twin Peaks was soon cancelled, and by 1992 Lynch’s popularity seemed to have completely reversed. The critics panned his film Twin Peaks: Fire Walk With Me, calling him and his American style of surrealism old hat and even his comic strip The Angriest Dog in the World was cancelled. “It was a bad year,” Lynch said. But he kept painting, kept doing photography, and kept making movies in his compulsive obstinance. He just continued what he did before 1990. Retrospectively, did he just spend those years painting, the four years struggling to make Eraserhead while delivering newspapers, followed by ups and downs making films, just to get one year of peak fame? I don’t think so.

BUT!

I also don’t think Lynch wants to be the anonymous guy painting in his studio since he’s embraced the online world of self-promotion more than others. Before ever making films, he traveled to Austria to apprentice under famed expressionist painter Oskar Kokoschka (only to come home quickly). He applied to the AFI film program—the premier film school in the US—before ever making Eraserhead (shot in the barn at the AFI premises) and took work at major studios for films like The Elephant Man and Dune. He’s admittedly obsessed with old Hollywood icons like Marilyn Monroe and Rita Hayworth. He played the Hollywood game. None of this happened accidentally. There was at least some intent behind it. To Lynch’s credit, he did retain most of his artistic integrity through the process, refusing major offers (like directing Return of the Jedi) over more personal work.

With Lynch’s example and others, I’d contend that fame is rarely accidental. As poet Czelaw Milosz wrote, “Life rarely takes care of itself unless human beings decide to take care of themselves.” Someone like Solzhenitsyn intended to win a Nobel Prize. He intended it before he ever wrote one word: “I had heard of them (the Nobel ceremonies) from someone, I forget who it was, in the camps. And at once drew a conclusion in the spirit of our country…that this was just what I needed to make my great breakthrough when the time came,” reasoning, “No one, of course, wants to be the author only of ‘posthumous works’; live just long enough to see yourself in print and you can die happy.” It was the same Solzhenitsyn who walked into the offices of Novy Mir, the premiere literature publication in the USSR, to submit his manuscript for One Day in the Life of Ivan Denisovich. He claimed to be nervous—he probably was!—reluctant—probably was!—even noted he thought he’d never see his work published in his lifetime—probably true! Frustration, and even resignation, mix in the sediment of our goals—especially as we get older and they seem more distant on the horizon. But no matter how much the sun has set, the sun—the prize—is still in our line of sight. The desire for fame or recognition, and the barriers life presents in the way, can lead to frustration and resignation, producing an overwhelming cacophony, and you don’t know where one thing starts and the other begins.

“You know how good CONTENT is, don’t you?” a friend asked me when he read an early manuscript.

Of course I knew. As I wrote it, I thought I had something special. I wanted everyone to know. But there were doubts along the way. It hasn’t sold many copies, so the doubts are even greater after the fact. But I trust my friend’s assessment because he has good literary taste. His praise should be satisfying enough, I suppose. But it isn’t. I want others to know, and at the very least living authors I admire to read and respect it. But that isn’t for me to determine. I can’t control when or what they read. Maybe people aren’t ready for CONTENT. Maybe they never will be.

Remember, fame and everything downstream of it is temporal and however much we intend, like 1990 for Lynch, it’s not so much fame that is fickle but the determinants of said fame, re: the “audience”, something we have little control over. Twin Peaks was a popular show for one year but its ratings fell and the taste for the show waned. Why? Bad writing? The fact it was scheduled on a different night? Audiences found something better to watch? Probably all three.

Audiences lose their taste for something for a variety of reasons. When I was a kid, I recorded the cover of Cat’s in the Cradle by Ugly Kid Joe off the radio. When my cousin visited, he played it over and over again. Listen. Rewind tape. Listen again.  

Rewind tape. Over and over. After that moment, I never listened to Ugly Kid Joe again—and I’m sure my cousin will say the same. The band had no control over it. Another song I recorded: Under the Bridge by Red Hot Chili Peppers. I listened to it daily, over and over. But then I stopped listening…until my little brother bought me the band’s greatest hits album years later. And I listened to them again…for about a month. Thinking about all this 15 years later, I downloaded the same album off Apple Music. Red Hot Chili Peppers had no control over my fickle mood. The only control they had was just consistently playing music, so they can have compilation albums or new material for me and others to discover once we are in the mood to listen and explore. But pop bands have a small window. Their young audiences “grow up” and then head for a new music that is more “adult” and don’t want the artists of their youth to grow up with them. Duran Duran had a more “mature” sound with their 1987 Notorious album, but their now adult fans wanted to listen to the more youthful music of Rio or Seven & the Ragged Tiger of 1983. They wanted to listen to the music of their youth to feel youthful, an audio fountain of youth. It’s only when a younger generation can revisit and appreciate the entire catalogue of a respective artist in perspective, that they get a worthy assessment and possibly greater accolades. In my case, I was a little young for Duran Duran’s prime, but my older brother liked them (in a way, the slightly younger initializing the first comprehensive retrospectives of their elder sibling’s favorite acts is a form of “little brother syndrome”). Sometimes the youth in older age start feeling a nostalgia now that they have some more disposable income, and if the musical act is still around, they can benefit with higher ticket sales and touring. But I digress, a little.

The same happens in all creative spheres, even among intellectual appreciation. I remember a college professor saying “Henry James was really popular when I was in college”, 100 years removed from his death but he was no longer “hot”. The Abstract Expressionists were a popular artistic movement until they weren’t. The Western was a popular film genre until it wasn’t. Trends, moods and concerns change. As they change, people who claimed to be admirers also change their assessment of their admiration. Walter Kirn, whose review of Infinite Jest helped jumpstart its fame, now thinks he overpraised it. Steppling related a story how he talked with others about Abstract Expressionism and they replied “I don’t think I ever liked it.” Titanic was the top film of all time…but now falls on top of lists like “The Worst Films Ever Made”. It’s akin to someone telling their lover, “I don’t love you anymore. I don’t know if I ever did.” In a way, they’re ashamed they got caught up in the tide of emotion and passion that accompanies love and are now trying to distance from it at low ebb. Or maybe they’ve discovered a new fact: “You’re not the man I thought you were”. When Solzhenitsyn started exploring historical literature, expanding beyond anti-Stalinism, he lost support among those closest to him. At other times, accolades turning to jeers is also a form of trying to justify a new love. Solzhenitsyn’s influence in post-Soviet Russia, after his return there, was minimized due to a Russian public, that formerly logocentric culture, had stopped reading literature. As Solomon Volkov noted, “The public writers were no longer writers and poets but pop musicians, film actors, and television celebrities, as it is everywhere else.”

No wonder artists like to easily portray themselves as martyrs. Tarkovsky enjoyed fame with his first feature film, Ivan’s Childhood, winning the top prize at the Venice Film Festival (having a giant like Jean-Paul Sartre championing his film!), only to meet frustrations with the films proceeding. He called his diary Martyrology, even though he had the full support of Mosfilm to helm his films and eventually European financing. Echoing the Hagiographies chapter, many artists have a tendency to participate and lead their own mythmaking, martyrdom being a recurring feature. But many knew what they were getting into. But, with fickle crowds and patrons, it’s easy to feel like a martyr to circumstance. So, it helps to use said story to propagate your fame. People love a sympathetic hero.

And those who claim to never want fame? Upon some more reflection, it’s more than just a statement of moral superiority. If they didn’t want fame, they’d probably never think about it. “How do you like my chairs?” the barista, also a professional upholsterer, asked me as I sat in a chair at the café. Obviously, she wanted some recognition along with some conversation. The anonymous designers and builders of Chartres Cathedral? Maybe it never entered their mind. Maybe. The lack of authorship adds to its greatness. We never question its authenticity or its stature. Its very existence sits as a testament to it. The one who claims to not want fame? Maybe it’s a fear of fame. A premeditated egotistic statement of avoidance to avert disappointment, like a man who swears fealty to bachelorhood because he doesn’t “need” women or love. Maybe he’s just scared of failure or has been hurt enough. Ego and fear exist together. They originate in fragility, and fame is certainly dangerous for the fragile. Fear dominates the ego, because there’s always the chance you could be revealed as a fraud, not good enough. Failure could damage the fragile ego the most.

I would certainly know.

Sunday, September 25, 2022

MT White The Artist’s Fortitude Fame

MT White
The Artist’s Fortitude
Fame




Who am I to write about this topic?

It’s easy to mistake narcissism for fame.

BUT!

In our modern era, it’s easier than ever to develop a degree of fame with a certain niche. The long tail is one feature of the social media world that is both positive and negative. You can reach an audience, but it can also give you a bloated sense of self-importance while also pigeonholing you at same time. For many, this may be enough. I’m reminded of those in my hometown of Bryan, Texas, who thought their position at the local Texas A&M University, or their monopolistic hold on a certain business in the town (like the artist Benjamin Knox who is kind of the unofficial court artist for the university or the local TV sports anchor), in which they wielded their fame with a disproportionate egotism. A couple of examples: 1) Knox allegedly told a co-worker of mine that his signing a document was a big deal with such a repulsive cockiness, she felt need to note it. 2) The local sports anchor, kind of an institution, tried to get a discount on some electronics at a local store by asking (without irony), “Do you know who I am?” Every small town, especially in the South, has their self-declared barons, a big fish in a small pond. Cyberspace is no different.

But it can give you an idea about fame, even if you haven’t appeared on Page Six or TMZ or been chased by paparazzi.

I think many artists want some fame or at the very least are curious about it. When someone tells me, “I don’t care about being famous,” I sense it’s just a protective statement either to not sound narcissistic or just declare themselves morally superior (a form of narcissism).

In a sphere like the arts, where “purity” is valued, it does make sense for one to be suspicious of fame and the famous, thinking they made some sort of devil’s bargain to attain it or (gulp) produced a work so amazingly generic that it appealed to a large number of people. But on the reverse side, one might want to have prestige, its own form of fame, lacking a monetary reward, as David Foster Wallace noted, “If you write philosophy books, you’re basically worrying a whole lot about what other philosophers think, and that’s just about it.”

It’s natural to want a modicum of recognition for your work because, let’s face it, in order to have any degree of influence you must be known by at least the “right” people, whether it be the powerful few or the masses.

Every artist referenced in this book had some form of fame, whether it be in their lifetime or posthumous. The latter case, like Vincent Van Gogh, or Franz Kafka is actually rarer than the former. Some like Dostoevsky, Braque, Gauguin, Fitzgerald or Herman Melville, were known commodities in their lifetimes, but their work became more appreciated and famous afterwards. Others, like Gore Vidal or Zane Grey, had their fame die with them.

I think many artists were inspired by a mass medium at the very least. I started drawing because of comics and to draw characters like Spider-man or Batman. Movies that awakened my sense of visual aesthetics as a teen, like Nikita, Brazil and Blade Runner, were not independent or experimental films but major releases. Up until recently, even the most avant garde work required some form of distribution and promotion in the biggest cities to gain notice. We know about early David Lynch or Stanley Brakhage or Chantal Akerman because someone found their works important enough to promote and distribute them. We know about the likes of Abstract Expressionists like Jackson Pollock because Peggy Guggenheim gave him patronage and got his work displayed at uptown New York galleries. Niche fame, but fame and favor nonetheless; respect given by a certain set.

Most artists want art to be their sole concern, and today this requires income. This income is usually provided by a patron who feels that by paying you their investment will be returned (a publisher, a movie studio, an art gallery, a record label etc.), or a patron who feels they are nurturing a talent that has yet to be fully appreciated (this can be in the form of a person or an endowment or the same entities listed above). In literature, JD Salinger received carte blanche because his books sold but Cormac McCarthy needed grants from endowments to support his writing until his work alone could support him. Jim Harrison got $50,000 from his friend Jack Nicholson. In film, Steven Spielberg got a mostly blank check. Robert Altman and Woody Allen had the favor of certain studio bosses, regardless of box office performance. Someone with money or influence was aware of and appreciated their talent.

Fame, recognition, and the sometimes monetary rewards that follow are very much prerequisites for legitimacy, artistic or otherwise. Example: I gave a female receptionist a copy of an essay I wrote, but she’s yet to read it…and yet, there she is at her desk reading Viktor Frankl because her favorite YouTubers recommended it. Frankl was designated more legitimate and urgent to read than me (someone she personally knows) because of his past and who championed him. Such is life. In the US at least, fame also gives one a form of moral legitimacy, that somehow attaining success legitimizes every other aspect of one’s life, decisions both personal and public (notice how, regardless of respective political or religious belief, when a celebrity expresses their support for said belief, the adherents celebrate it). Actors think their celebrity gives their political views weight. A billionaire like Bill Gates thinks he can lecture about and determine a global vaccination protocol. Billionaires like Ross Perot and Donald Trump thought they should be President. Most self-help and motivational literature is geared towards helping and motivating one to “keep going” in order to achieve their “dreams” (which is success at whatever task). The social media app Cameo features mostly celebrities mostly bequeathing their admonitions to “hang in there”, to respective, unknown individuals, even though they were paid to say it, yet somehow seeing a celebrity mouth the scripted, yet personally directed words, like a cipher, somehow will divine something. As playwright John Steppling observed: “Ambition has replaced curiosity.” And really, that’s why I’ve mainly excluded the platforms of the internet, like self-publishing, streaming, social media etc. These are just mass, electronic extensions of the avenues always available to independent artists. One could always self-publish or self-exhibit, the tools have just become more sophisticated. But it’s rooted mainly in ambition, with success of the respective artist geared on sheer numbers, on volume, the masses determining what is of value (and since when has the crowd been deemed smarter or worthier in determining talent?). It’s all based on ego, meaning it is at the not highest level of engagement and thought but the lowest. Self-publishing used to be called “vanity publishing” for a reason.

Living in the success obsessed results oriented NOW can warp an artist’s work and (excuse the word) motivation to varying degrees. I remember watching a documentary about Karate in Okinawa. During a sparring session, the instructor, a strict, older Okinawan yelled at his British student for concentrating too much on “winning” rather than participating in the natural exchange of Uke (loosely translated as “receiving”), just letting oneself be in the moment of the fight instead of concentrating solely on the knockout blow or winning. Many Japanese arts stress this flow in a sense. In traditional combat sports, like Kyudo, Kendo, or Sumo, there are ceremonial actions that must be performed before the contest. The contest is certainly important but so are the ceremonial rites before. The same with a traditional art like Tea Ceremony. The Maccha prepared is naturally important but so are the rituals performed making it and the rituals of drinking it. It’s an appreciation of the entire flow and unity of things. An artist, purely chasing success, can corrupt this. As novelist Karl Ove Knausgaard noted about his work, “I knew so much about what people liked, I completely lost authenticity in the writing.”

In seeking success, the artist may upset their flow, denying a certain natural course of action, like making something opaque or confrontational (like Abstract Expressionist painting), and persuade themselves to make something easily digestible and “commercial” (like Bob Ross or Thomas Kinkaide). The audience or critics or influencers and their respective opinions will haunt them as they work on their creations. While this is certainly a natural state of affairs regardless—no one exists alone—it can become heightened and all-consuming about pleasing THEM, a (mostly unidentified) mass who the artist will probably never meet or at very most have limited engagement with, and yet, this mass looms like an invisible zombie horde because the artist wants their cash or approval. In our long-tail niche world, it actually might become more warped. The artist might not want to upset their hyper particular audience by going even slightly off-script—you don’t want to anger your core audience. The purity spiral can drain quickly into a struggle session…But we are citizens of this hyper-modern world and therefore are products of its time. We desire fame or at the very least recognition from either those more famous or whom we esteem, seeing it as the gods bestowing us some favor by just looking in our direction. Indie filmmaker and instructor Rick Schmidt, a person very much against the Hollywood system, noted how after all his struggles to make his film 1988: The Musical, he ran into a drunk Dennis Hopper at a film festival and received praise from the famous actor. The climatic reward of going through divorce and financial hardship for a film is a verbal pat on the back from a notorious yet washed-up actor? Whatever helps justify the struggle. To promote Schmidt’s book Feature Filmmaking at Used Car Prices, the copy states how the book is “credited with influencing filmmakers Kevin Smith, Vin Diesel, Tom DiCillo and many others.” The subtext is clear: You read this book, you too could be successful like the aforementioned. Forget the fact the contents of the book betray the back-cover sales copy (the introduction by Ray Carney immediately nukes commonly held notions of commercial filmmaking).

But Schmidt isn’t alone. Whenever I’ve had someone more widely known than myself praise my work, I’m quick to inform family and friends. I have friends who have done the same. It’s just in our nature. If Dennis Hopper said he loved my work, I’d probably say the ends justified the means.

But fame is mostly fleeting. And fickle.

Tuesday, August 9, 2022

MT WHITE The Artist’s Fortitude 'Hagiographies'

We continue our serialisation of MT White’s upcoming new magnum opus, The Artist’s Fortitude. It would be impolite of us not to mention this particular chapter first appeared in the esteemed PunchRiot magazine some months ago. I wasn’t going to mention it, but MT felt I should.

MT WHITE

The Artist’s Fortitude

 

Hagiographies


Myth never died. As “reason” and “enlightenment” progress in modernity, myth only expands to all realms—especially to the realm of the artist.

Artists are subject to mythmaking just as much as anyone else, in both work and biography—but really, they’re one & the same. But! As Aristotle said: “the poets tend to lie a lot”. They want their stories, the personal stories they tell, to have a dramatic arc. It’s only natural. I’d say it kind of adds to their allure. In “The Magical Chorus”, Russian musicologist Solomon Volkov points out how many Soviet era artists, like film director Andrei Tarkovsky and poets like Anna Akhtamova, Yevgeny Yetvushenko, and Joseph Brodsky, willfully created and participated in their own mythmaking (Yetvushenko, for example, told everyone he was born in a village called Zima Junction because it sounded more “poetic” rather than Nizhneudinsk—the actual village in which he was born). It’s only natural…

There are the stories about “overnight” successes: Sylvester Stallone wrote “Rocky” in two days; Joe Eszterhas wrote “Basic Instinct” in just 10 days then sold it for $3 million; Michael Des Barres wrote the song Obsession in 10 minutes and it made him “at least” $3 million; Quentin Tarantino used to work at a video store until he directed “Reservoir Dogs”…

The problem with success hagiographies, and artist myths in general, is there’s a great chance artists will be aware of them. And they are informing not necessarily with faulty information but with information out of a certain context, a context formed to cater to the emotional masses, selling them a romantic story to build their legend (what does it matter to the average Ivan where Yevgeny Yetvushenko is really from?). This is true outside the creative sphere as well. In business, knowing about the “genius” of Steve Jobs makes me more loyal to the Apple product. It’s why we rarely hear about the Apple III, the NeXT computer (a 10-year concern for Jobs) or Pixar originally intended as a hardware company—all failures Jobs oversaw. And if we do hear about them, it is always in the context of how the failure led to success. Same goes for someone like George Lucas: Knowing about his struggles making the first “Star Wars” film (“Everyone was against him,” “No one thought Science Fiction was a viable genre”, “no one believed in the film”, “he didn’t have the budget he needed to really make the film he envisioned” etc.), helps me enjoy its success and the movies all the more.

But as an artist, a lonely, atomized artist, it can cause disillusion because I haven’t experienced same.

This kind of leads into another type of hagiography, that of “The Artist as Saint” or “blessed personality”. Actually, there’s no clear lines here. The “success myth” blends a lot with the “blessed personality” myth. “They are (were) a genius,” being a common refrain among friends and collaborators, waxing nostalgic with anecdotes about how exciting and enlightening it was to work or meet with them, the halos only glowing more and more in the literary and filmed portraits that follow in the artist’s wake. A recent example of this is the film “The End of the Tour” about novelist David Foster Wallace, which Bret Easton Ellis called “reverential to a fault.” Ellis used his review of the film to note how it ignored the darker side of Wallace, “the contemptuous man, the sometime-contrarian, the asshole with an abusive side, the cruel critic.” An obstacle for hagiographies like this film is having to explain the dark events of real life, like Wallace’s suicide, while keeping the halo lit. So, their handling is a portrayal of Wallace as, in Ellis’ words, of a man “too sensitive for this world,” whereas Walter Kirn contends the suicide was a result of David Foster Wallace hating “being David Foster Wallace,” (meaning he couldn’t enjoy or obtain the fringe benefits of fame—like money and women). But the film is just fiction, just a story…

A documentary example of this type of hagiography is “A Constant Forge”, about independent film pioneer John Cassavetes. Ray Carney, an authority on Cassavetes and participant in the documentary called it all “a joke”, trying to “sell us this sentimental soap-opera version of who Cassavetes was. It’s not true. It’s a fairy-tale account,” noting the doc omitted mention of his negative personality traits resulting in “the rankest of hero-worship. Cassavetes has no shortcomings and flaws. He has no tangibility, no reality.”

Why is this kind of documentary bad for the aspiring artists who watch? Carney again: “Young filmmakers will watch this movie and fall for its lies. And then they will think they are not right or normal, because their lives are not this way.”

Once again, disillusionment for the artist raises its ugly specter when consuming this type of hagiography, usually in a sea of confusion, because their watching may be at cross purposes with the intent of the documentary. In the case of “A Constant Forge”, Pioneer commissioned the documentary to promote a planned home video set of the director’s work, then Criterion added it to their DVD box set—it was just intended to promote and amplify enjoyment of a product, not inspire budding filmmakers. Whereas the success hagiography (the Lucas example) makes one feel they are falling short in a material or status sense, the “blessed personality” hagiography makes you feel you’re just a failure as a human. In a sense, this latter type may be more dangerous. You question your own life as being lacking or worthless, possibly leading to believing your life is worthless, therefore thinking you have no worthwhile art.

Many a time, these types of hagiographies are concocted by outsiders looking in. Would Lucas, Cassavetes or Wallace write their personal autobiographies as hagiographies? Probably not, but at the same time, they or their estates carefully stage manage the presentations before they even agree to participate.

Because being candid and revelatory about one’s past can open one up for trouble. When F. Scott Fitzgerald wrote “The Crack-Up” for “Esquire”, his honest three-part essay about his mental collapse, he received nothing but criticism from the likes of John Dos Passos and Ernest Hemingway. The latter said it, “seems to almost take a pride in his shamelessness of defeat…I always knew he couldn’t think—he never could—but he had a marvelous talent and the thing is to use it—not whine in public.” 

Both Fitzgerald and Hemingway died from complications from alcohol. Fitzgerald, himself a football player and soldier, is regarded historically as the more tragic yet fragile figure. Hemingway, who marketed an image as tough guy, maintains that image posthumously though he’s the one who committed suicide and enjoyed playing the role of female in the bedroom…

When someone is frank, like Fitzgerald or Joe Eszterhas in his memoirs, it can have a helpful, almost therapeutic effect. One can find inspiration knowing they are not alone in whatever they are struggling with. St. Augustine—an actual saint—pioneered the autobiographical form, being honest about his failings in his “Confessions”.

Of course, when talking about “failings”, there is a danger of falling into a synography—actually, artists today tend to veer closer to this form when discussing their lives, almost taking a masochistic glee in how “bad” they behaved. “The Dirt”, a film about hard rock band Motley Crue takes a hedonistic joie de vivre about their party lifestyle. Henry Miller’s semi-autobiographical novel “Tropic of Cancer”, has the author hilariously describe his sexual escapades through France while also lamenting his pathetic character. Even in fictional form, the film “Sideways”, based on a novel by Rex Pickett, has the novelist protagonist portrayed as close to pathetic schlub with only scant redeeming qualities (and his actor friend in the film receives same treatment). In both books and documentaries about Dennis Hopper, a majority of the discussion about the actor/director revolves around his drug use and “wild behavior”, like firing guns in hotel rooms with flaming mattresses flying out the window, or hitting on his daughter’s classmates at her high school graduation. It’s at times both equally horrifying and entertaining, but ultimately depersonalized, also dispelling any sense of tangibility and reality. Discussing how “bad” someone is just a direct inverse of only discussing how “good” someone is. Both are forms of propaganda. Being a bad boy who can do no right is just as fallacious and damaging a story as the good boy who can do no wrong. Just as the hagiography can make the artist feel they are not “right or normal” so can the synography—if I’m not “bad” or “crazy” enough, maybe I’m not really exploring and flexing my creative juices. Just another form of insecurity and disillusionment…

And of course, the thing about artist hagiographies is you’re eventually going to find out the truth if you dig deep enough, and what then, when the façade is broken?

BUT!

As Fitzgerald wrote in The Crack-Up: “Of course all life is a process of breaking down…“

The image of holy artist shattering can have an adverse side effect—at least it did for me: I started exploring the cinema of Andrei Tarkovsky after reading an article about him in a “filmmakers of faith” section on the “Christianity Today” website. The summary wasn’t a bio, just a brief discussion of his films and how related to his faith. I just projected/assumed the fundamentalist Christian values common to someone living in the southern United States. “Sculpting in Time”, Tarkovsky’s meditation on his life and work, written before his death, didn’t really betray this image of sainted filmmaker—neither did his solemnly titled diary collection “Martyrology”. But obsessive that I am, I dug deeper into his life. He was far from a saint. He had priapic tendencies to say the least. He left his first wife, an actress, for another woman, also an actress, and impregnated another woman in Sweden before he died. On the set of his film “Stalker”, he maliciously demeaned the celebrated cinematographer Georgi Rerberg, eventually firing him. In fact, the film had to be shot three times, with three different cinematographers, basically due to Tarkovsky’s recklessness, and even though his patron at Mosfilm, Fedor Ermash, did everything to help Tarkovsky finish the film, the director lambasted him in “Martyrology”. For all his lamenting of materialism in “Sculpting in Time” and his films, he basically defected to the West, renouncing his Soviet citizenship, leaving his son behind in Russia, mainly for material reasons (some say due to pressure from his second wife). His friend and cinematographer Vadim Yusov met him in Italy, shocked at the loud, stylish clothes his friend now wore. One collaborator noted Tarkovsky was weak and indecisive in all aspects of his life except his art. Maybe his early death at age 54 led to this hagiography overtaking this image? After the director’s death, Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn criticized Tarkovsky’s “Andrei Rublev”, bringing outrage in the Third Wave Emigrant community. “Tarkovsky, it turns out, had been deified,” wrote Solzhenitsyn.

Was I disappointed to discover this information? An understatement. Maybe the disappointment comes from viewing works that are so “high”, it is hard to fathom the artist living a life so “low”. But it’s a part of life. We want icons to admire, even as artists, a life to aspire to. When I discussed a previous relationship with someone I mentored, she asked that I refrain from talking about it. “I don’t want to think any less of you.” Why, in our imperfection do we want others to be perfect? Is it because the mirror image of our own likeness is so awful that we want there to be someone better, someone higher? We want the potential of that hope to be fulfilled? Could it be, we want to escape the mundane mix of good and bad that permeates our existence?

In regards to Tarkovsky, I do know one thing that does not betray his life and image: His films. His characters usually have a passive quality about them, almost taking on the role of martyr. In “Andrei Rublev”, the title character—an artist and monk—is tempted into sex with a naked pagan woman. A young man lies about his credentials as a bell-maker to get a royal commission—yet, he succeeds and it brings him to tears. In “Solaris”, the lead can’t stop his ex-wife from continually committing suicide—a metaphor for the memories that haunt us? At the start of “Stalker”, the title character leaves his wife and child to fulfill his “mission” of escorting people to the alien and mystical territory of “The Zone”—only to return disillusioned. In “Mirror”, the director’s most autobiographical film, a dying man recalls his past (his estranged wife played by the same actress who plays his mother) in the intersection against the bigger backdrop of Russian culture, history and faith. Tarkovsky’s father (who left him at an early age) was a poet. And in a way, his own way, Tarkovsky’s films are poetry too. The poetry of a flawed human trying to piece things together through cinematic imagery, echoing philosopher Lev Shestov’s observation: “Men reveal the most painful and significant truth only when not speaking directly about themselves.”

One documentary featuring Tarkovsky, “Rerberg and Tarkovsky: The Reverse Side of ‘Stalker’”, almost acts as a harmatography, or character assassination, in order to make the great cameraman Rerberg look like a martyr himself. These sorts of portrayals are legion as well. A clear example is the documentary “Overnight”, about director Troy Duffy, which is edited to make him appear as the most hateful and egotistical person to have ever lived as he tries to realize his film “The Boondock Saints”. These works are trying to topple the idols, so to speak, whether it be their artistic acumen (like Pauline Kael trying to diminish Orson Welles’ contributions to “Citizen Kane”) or just portray them as horrible people to almost delegitimize their work (how many articles have been written about Picasso abusing his seven muses?). Solzhenitsyn himself was the object of scorn in books published in both Russia and the West. His first wife, Natalya Reshetovskaya, wrote a memoir (Sanya) portraying him as an overbearing, egomaniacal womanizer who forbade her to bear children because it would interfere with his writing. Olga Carlisle, who smuggled Solzhenitsyn’s “The First Circle” and “The Gulag Archipelago” into the West and translated them into English, wrote her own pejorative memoir about her dealings with him.

Many artists have questionable events in their past both personal and political. JD Salinger, Elvis Presley, Roman Polanski, Woody Allen, Fyodor Dostoevsky—all had more than questionable pasts with underage girls. Ezra Pound and Louis-Ferdinand Céline supported Fascism. Boris Pasternak and Dmitri Shostakovich pledged support and wrote odes to Stalin. TS Eliot and Walt Disney were anti-Semites. Valerie Solanas shot Andy Warhol for a reason. Nobody is perfect.

The problem with harmatologies is the budding artist, depending on the fragility of their ego, may become incredibly self-conscious in their actions and artistic practice, afraid of what others may say about them—especially in this very public social media age. This is probably the reason why many err on the side of masochistic synographies, whether bragging or mourning their “bad” behavior—there’s more than a bit of narcissism involved, but it’s better to promote and manage this information yourself, getting out in front of others who will use it for their own agendas (“Art School Confidential”—a film where an aspiring artist accepts accusations of him being a serial killer in order to achieve fame is a good satire of this inclination).

Harmatologies are usually the product of a scorned party or an uninvolved participant. The former are understandable, whether it be for political reasons (the KGB published and most likely wrote Reshetovskaya’s memoir to get at Solzhenitsyn) or personal (the producers of “Overnight” were former friends of director Duffy). Reading or watching a work like this provides a thrill, like reading a gossip column for juicy details omitted from hagiographies, almost a pornography of information. The latter type of harmatography, written by the uninvolved, like a “scholar” or journalist, are more malicious, a product of Pharisees judging a life or work they had no part in. They are just jealous, or fearful, of both the potential of a work and facing their own mediocrity.

An artist must live in order to create. Harmony Korine advised that artists should explore extremes. I don’t think a creative type can help but explore extremes whether they be sexual, chemical, religious or ideological.

In the example of Fitzgerald, being honest about one’s life and struggle can be a dangerous act. It upsets both admirers and detractors—basically everyone—for opposite reasons. They’re angered by either the extremes of love or hate being upturned, at the disturbance of myth—whether it be that of saint or sinner—because in the end most desire myth, an escape from the turbulence and chaotic nuance of this life. They don’t desire a reminder. Fitzgerald: “and there are always those to whom all self-revelation is contemptible, unless it ends with a noble thanks to the gods for the Unconquerable Soul.”

But the work outlives bad press. The only thing that stands the test of time—if it stands the test of time—is the artistic work (a film like “Star Wars” looks more antiquated by the day). As Terry Gilliam said amidst the troubled production of “The Adventures of Baron Munchausen”: “I think my priorities are right. I will sacrifice myself or anyone else for the movie. It will last. We'll all be dust.”

Tuesday, August 2, 2022

THE CORRESPONDENCE OF ERNST GRAF & M.T.WHITE on the subject of V for VENDETTA & GUY FAWKES

 THE CORRESPONDENCE OF ERNST GRAF & M.T.WHITE 

on the subject of V for VENDETTA 

& GUY FAWKES


EG Friday 5th November 00:31

Have you seen this film? 

It's on at my local repertory cinema tomorrow and I'm curious to see it, with it turning Guy Fawkes into a world famous 'face' but I'm sure the cinema will be packed which I do not like.


MT 02:08

I have seen. And I hated it. Real pretentious piece of shit that somehow equates gay and Islamic persecution. Alan Moore, who wrote the original comic, also hated it.


EG 02:29

Yes just watched trailer, pretty risible, and Moore refused to have his name on the credits or take any royalties!

Think only extraordinary thing about it is the power it gave globally to the previously parochial English Guy Fawkes - every year now all round the world there are the ‘million mask marches’, everyone wearing that iconic Guy Fawkes mask.

It absolutely fascinates me the fact Guy Fawkes still 'lives' and has this cultural resonance more than 400 years after his failed attempt at 'terrorism'. This is why November 5th means so much to me.


MT 02:36

It certainly is fascinating. I drove by a protest outside a Scientology branch and all the protestors wore that mask. Quite a surreal sight. I actually knew about Guy Fawkes Day before that film ever cursed our screens, because it is celebrated in New Zealand, where my family lived for a few years. My father always mentioned it as the oddest holiday.

But if Fawkes was successful, we might not have the King James Bible, which as far as language goes, is just as influential as Shakespeare. So it’s quite a fateful day for writers who use English, eh?


EG 03:33

There are so many levels to Guy Fawkes.

Such an ambivalent or dare I say multivalent cultural figure. We burn his effigy on bonfires to celebrate his torture 400 years after the event. Yet the Fawkes mask is a popular symbol of heroic freedom and dissent. 

Absolute right what you say about the KJB and Shakespeare. If you stopped people in the street and said to them can you quote me anything from the KJB or Shakespeare almost everyone would say they know nothing of either, yet without knowing it undoubtedly quote from both every single day of their lives. So many expressions from both have entered the language as common parlance without people knowing their original source. 

The phrases and idioms of MT White and Ernst Graf will I believe be similarly ubiquitous in centuries to come. (I feel another 'correspondence' is coming on.)


MT 04:04

I can’t imagine someone not knowing the King James Bible or Shakespeare! Actually, I can, sadly. But I grew up with both, and don’t want to think of a life otherwise.

I agree, the phrases and idioms of Ernst Graf and MT White will outlive us, even build a legend unheralded thanks to a power that gives “exceeding abundantly above all that we ask or think, according to the power that worketh in us”.

And likewise, our correspondences will be studied in schools, or back alleyways of a totalitarian state, or both.


I didn’t say it to MT but hundreds of thousands of these Guy Fawkes masks are sold every year, which must make it (covid face nappies aside) the best-selling mask of all time, and every dime & cent of it goes to...Time Warner. In his current state I feared if I’d said this to MT now it would have broken him once & for all, so I didn’t. This is friendship.




Sunday, July 31, 2022

The Artist’s Fortitude by MT White 'Obstinance'

 The Artist’s Fortitude

By MT White


Obstinance


Felt a need to title this chapter “Obstinance”. Not sure why. Looked up the definition online and found: “Stubbornly refusing to change one’s opinion or chosen course of action, despite attempts to persuade one to do so.”


The “chosen course of action” in question here is making art, being an artist.


Who or what is trying to persuade us otherwise from creation?


Loved ones, circumstances, the world itself with its institutions and economic structures, you know, life in general. But we ourselves are also trying to persuade ourselves to stop. At least one side of us…



Recently, after watching an interview with Tom Wolfe on YouTube, I wrote the following in my notebook: “Tom Wolfe said (on “Firing Line”) an author should be popular, citing those like (Emile) Zola and (Yukio) Mishima. One should only be considered ‘pure literature’ if it’s ‘pure’. But my literature isn’t ‘pure’. And I have no support system, like an inheritance or endowment, grants etc. So, it’s either go popular or go home. Which begs the question: Why the fuck am I doing this? You should only do things for love or money. And I neither love this nor am I making any money and I hardly have any notice. I’ve been doing this (writing novels) for 13 years and the dividends have been minimal. Nothing is forcing me to continue. Is it God-given talent I’m denying (by not writing)? I don’t know. I suppose if you don’t know then you do know.”


The entry immediately after: “I have close to nothing to show for it (writing). I wrote for money and fame. I failed to acquire either of them.”


There’s pages more of lament but I won’t burden you with them. But here’s the final entry after concluding it all a hobby: “I want to enjoy my hobby, not hate it. I’ve come close to hating writing. Yet, I’m still collecting notes (for a forthcoming novel).”


I feel depressed just revisiting said notes. But it’s a snapshot of where my mind was, and where it can wander from time to time.


And the concluding note…haunts? “Yet, I’m still collecting notes”…


A novel in the back of my mind for years. Collecting and collecting…


Habit? Obstinance? Probably both.


Emotions are fickle, especially when it comes to things important to us. In the span of a day or the span of a minute, we can run the gamut of emotions from love to hate, elation to despair. But sometimes, one overarching emotion sits with us, like despair, with infrequent and brief visitations from counter emotions. 


For all the admirable wisdom of the Stoics and even that of later philosophers—like Immanuel Kant and Arthur Schopenhauer—it’s easy to get discouraged by external circumstances (objective events). Training inner (subjective) resolve is quite a task that we are not always up to…and let’s be honest: The artistic/creative type tends to be more sensitive than most.


So, the persuasive discouragement from our inner voice can ring loudly at times, even overpowering us.


And it isn’t always wrong.


Sometimes we just need to stop. Even quit. Or at the very least, take a break.


For writing, I’m not a believer in the theory that one must write every day, as stated by commercially successful writers like Stephen King, Steven Pressfield and even literary novelists like Larry McMurtry. They’re all more accomplished than me, but there’s a good chance they are attributing a dubious habit to their success (because all three are from working class backgrounds?), a survivorship bias. A counterexample is Georges Simenon, who only wrote three months out of the year, and was equally successful (maybe even more so) than those above, or Jim Harrison, who wrote “Legends of the Fall” in only nine days and felt you should let a work just build up inside of you before you sit down to write it. In other fields, there’s the likes of Abstract Expressionist painter Jackson Pollock, who only painted between long bouts of alcoholic binges. Another bias is that of privilege: They are all professionals, after all. They can write, paint, or whatever daily because they are paid to. It’s like saying, “Do your job” every day. There’s multiple reasons for someone’s success. Habits are one of multiple factors, superseded by things like connections, talent or just the pure luck of producing at a time when the market conditions are ideal for what you are selling (the talent of business acumen mattering more than the talent of writing—or any other type of art).


For those of us not full-timers, the frustration or exhaustion can set in as the years go by, seemingly with little progress made. There’s also the effect of having another job, regardless of what said job is—whatever pays the bills and puts food on the table. The fact we are doing another task, dedicating our time to it day in and day out at the expense of what we feel is our true vocation, will affect us mentally, spiritually and even physically. 


When I participated in an AMA with Bret Easton Ellis, I asked him about his editing process. In my question, I used the phrase “revise accordingly” which seemed to bother Ellis. He chided me in his reply for using such a “corporate” phrase. In retrospect, he was right. But I work in the corporate world. It has affected me to my deepest core in the words I use (like “revise accordingly”), the way I interact with others (guarded or even canned conversations), and the way I see the world. This is reflected in my novels and essays. I can use and have used it as a tool of reflection, a perspective from inside the belly of the beast. Bret, on the other hand, from a financially well-off family, has been a professional writer since college (when “Less Than Zero” was published and became a best-seller). His experience is different. But every worthwhile artist’s experience is reflected throughout their work, like a diamond reflecting light in multifaceted ways, depending on the angle. Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn’s eight-year experience in the Gulag, and subsequent exile in Kazakhstan (where he worked as a math teacher and wrote in the evenings), informed his work more than just providing raw material. It also set him on a path to question the very foundational existence of the USSR, to the point he felt like a foreigner in his native Russia.


But the fact we must “work”, modern society’s demanding it, takes a toll. As psychiatrist Peadar O’Grady noted, a person’s “ability to work” is the gauge of their mental health (Someone unable to work? Prescribe them some drugs!), whereas the root cause of mental distress (workplace conditions/financial concerns) is rarely discussed—and if they are discussed, it’s only in the most superficial way. 


This permeates the cultural environment at large—even for artists. Phrases like “writer’s block” have a negative connotation: You can’t write, implying you can’t produce. It’s purely pejorative. The refusal or inability to produce is seen as flighty or weak. David Mamet told actors not to “internalize the industrial model” but it has been internalized at almost every level.


This quote from Yamamoto Tsunetomo’s “Hagakure” inspired this chapter: “A Samurai should be excessively obstinate. Anything done in moderation will fall short of your goals. If you feel that you are doing more than is needed, it will be just right.”


Of course, the Samurai were a privileged class but as a ruling class they also had a duty: To their retainer and by extension, their fiefdom. 


And as an artist, when you do work, the question must be asked: “Who am I working for?”


Are you working for an audience? Applause? Yourself? God? A mixture of all? For Michel De Montaigne (also a member of the ruling class), an audience of the self was sufficient enough. Yet, for Tom Wolfe (not necessarily from the ruling class but upper class for sure), a work needed to be popular. Add to this the daily drudgery of a job with the rest of life’s challenges and things appear overwhelming.


But there is that silent thread of obstinacy in an artist… 


Artist Jeff Koons (comfortably middle-class) talked about walking on the street, feeling a physical pain while contemplating a potential work. I’ve felt same…


It’s here where inspiration can appear. Sometimes doing tasks on autopilot, or just having a routine, frees up the mind and that’s when ideas appear. We can’t help but think creatively. Ideas, concepts—they present themselves and it is then we have a choice to follow these seeds, help them grow, or ignore them.


As a working-class teenager, when I washed dishes in the kitchen of the hot deli at my local grocery store, I’d think of many ideas for the comic books I was planning or working on. I almost looked forward to doing the dishes in a way. Did any of these ideas come to fruition? Hardly. But it was an impulse I eventually started acting on more and more. 


One time, on the drive in to work, I thought about my novel “CONTENT”, which I was writing at the time. I forget why or what, but as I pulled into my parking space, I couldn’t help but think “I really care what others think.” Then I thought, “I care what you think.” Decided to start the novel stating outright, “I care what you think” which started an entire thread of ideas, becoming almost a mantra throughout the novel. Subsequently, it’s consistently mentioned by those who have read “CONTENT”. A creative victory from just doing something as innocuous as parking. 


This is where, I think, free will and choice play their part. The artistic impulse is a seed that needs to be watered. 


Does modern life retard this growth? Absolutely. The reason I didn’t act on my ideas as a teenager was mainly distractions and pure laziness. Our world is only growing in distractions, mainly with passive entertainment growing, which can only encourage laziness in the less conscientious of us. But throughout my search for entertainment, there was always that gnawing feeling…of creative ideas, whether it be book, movie, comic, art installation or whatever. After I actually started acting on some of these ideas, there was the gnawing idea of “failure”. 


Either way, there is a gnawing feeling. “Failure” is better of the two because 1) It’s a subjective definition (some have expressed jealousy at my life and accomplishments) 2) It could potentially reap dividends (forgive the corporate word) in the future and 3) It’s better to know you’ve been obstinate and done something than rather live with “what if’s”, while just watching TV, playing video games—being a consumer while being consumed. Obstinance feels better. 


As Solzhenitsyn said about his time in prison: “We are highly responsible for the development of the innate qualities nature bestows upon us.” He noted how his fellow prison inmates nurtured their respective positive or negative qualities while being locked up. Some became scoundrels, some became saints. He chose to nourish his creative nature, even if he didn’t have the best ingredients: He wrote passages on small scraps of paper or even committed whole works to memory, typing them up years later. In the Gulag, the worst of circumstances, Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn was obstinate. This continued in the years of exile, through the publication of “One Day in the Life of Ivan Denisovich” eight years later.


We may not have such a historical moment. I know I certainly haven’t. But what good are we doing otherwise, ignoring these artistic impulses? By at least creating, we are opening up possibilities. It’s better than nothing.


French film director Eric Rohmer said when he started making films, he decided that if he was consistent enough on a theme he would eventually gain some sort of following. I’ve experienced same. There’s billions of people in this world. There’s going to be at least a few who get you.


And an artist can’t help but create. And they don’t have to create to the demands of the modern world’s schedule. But if they are an artist, they will do…something. 


When I am doing something creative, when I feel I’m at the peak of mental taxation, that’s when I’ve done my best work, echoing the “Hagakure” passage. I’m NOT advising to work yourself to death. Actually, I’m not advising anything. Just reflecting on my own obstinance. There has been no great fiscal pay-off, hardly any critical accolades, save for those close to me.


But per Montaigne, that should be enough. It really should be because without any other reward, I would just be taxing myself, stressed out comparing results to the market model. Actually, that is what I did—and still do to an extent. But I started the slow, subtle shift to asking myself, the audience of one, if I was satisfied with my work. And it helped refuel the creatively obstinate nature, because the pressure, the burden to produce, was lifted.


But even then, it was just temporary relief.



M.T.White’s powerful & provocative novel CONTENT is available on Amazon at https://www.amazon.com/CONTENT-M-T-White-ebook/dp/B0877CNVRD. I called for it to be banned & pulped, they refused. “Combining provocation with apocalyptic vision, CONTENT presents a world on the brink of chaos as the forces of governments, technology, social media, ideology & religious cults vie for power & control of the masses.”


THE ART OF M.T.WHITE


Saturday, July 23, 2022

The Artist’s Fortitude By MT White Compulsion Part 2

 The Artist’s Fortitude

By MT White


Compulsion Part 2


When you watch YouTube videos with the same editing style, or go to the park and see couple after couple taking the same style photo, or look through Instagram and see the same caption with a girl raising her hands while looking at the sunset on the beach, or read book after book with the same clichéd characters and plots, or even notice that everyone is wearing the same style clothing with little variety, or even look at a calendar of paintings or dog photos at the grocery store, you realize they are just as canned as the canned beans on the grocery shelves. Replicas of replicas. The easy access to the creative technical tools just shows the lockstep mentality and lack of originality the masses possess. It has probably always been this way—that’s why artists were so heralded in the past: They had the exclusive vision and means to present a heightened vision. Now, everyone has the means but their lack of vision is apparent. For the artist of modern times, it presents itself to us in a myriad of ways daily, overwhelming us, while we get lost in the muddle of it all.

Maybe.

For the artist, especially the one trying to bring something new, something provoking, it can all be disheartening because today, it’s hard to escape. But an artist’s role is to break from this. Show a different path, even if it just leads to a path of replicators to follow. Because it’s not the tools but the eye or the mind of the artist that sees something…different, that others may not see, or rather makes obvious what was always there but was not articulated. This doesn’t mean the artist must always do something “new” or “fresh”. In fact, they may do something very old or ingrained but do it so well, it demands notice (In this respect, Akira Kurosawa referred to himself as an “artisan” not an “artist”). New can become old and hackneyed quickly. But after time, the old and hackneyed become new. Not an original observation but still. An artist’s job is to jolt, bring a new angle to a common view. Make the unseen seen or make the seen glow even brighter.

This takes fortitude. Especially today.

But this isn’t a book on aesthetics or cultural criticism. I’ve written about both respective subjects elsewhere.

And while it is most certainly not a motivational or “self-help” book, it is also not purely a negative book, meant to discourage. With an overflow of fluff, there is certainly a temptation to be the negative inverse of such. Being “real” or “telling it like it is” can be its own form of falsehood. Overreacting with negativity to counterbalance the positivity glut is just an exercise in being contrary. It results in an overcompensation of cynical sentiment, a need to be vulgar, denying any hope that may be present. While sometimes funny and maybe even sometimes necessary, it can drift into anachronism quickly, a corruption of ideas, responding to its corrupted opposite.

No, this book is just to let you know that however isolating you may feel, you are not entirely isolated…I guess?

I’m writing this in the Japanese Zuihitsu essay style, where I just follow “where the brush leads”, probably taking a cue from Junichiro Tanizaki’s In Praise of Shadows, his landmark essay on Japanese aesthetics.

But it was the Russian Solzhenitsyn who started me writing this. 

Reading his quote about the artist’s fortitude, in no uncertain terms, INSPIRED me. It triggered a flood of ideas, passages, and thoughts, especially as I walked around a State Park with my family, seeing couple after couple take the same photo with the mountains as backdrop. I spent that time in excitement, eager anticipation, of the potential book that awaited. 

But even I had doubts by the end of the day. I sent an email to a friend mentioning it, then dismissing it as a narcissistic distraction. I mean, who am I? I’m not famous or “successful” as an artist. There are certainly plenty of books about the art life out there. 

But the idea would not go away.

I’m compelled to write this.

Compulsion is a powerful force.

Underground artist Robert Williams said he did not paint out of enjoyment but compulsion. I share the sentiment.

So, here I am writing, despite the fact I have a novel I’ve been meaning to start and other life concerns.

Such is the way of the artist.

Even though it may not be my primary source of income, and though I may not look the part, I can confidently say I’m an artist. I’ve been called such both admiringly and pejoratively by others, but more importantly, I know it. When did I start as an artist? Childhood? Wandering the backyard, envisioning stories and adventures? My teen years? When I taught myself to draw, making or attempting to make comics and movies with friends? Adulthood? When I wrote movie screenplays—almost got a couple in production!—pivoting to novel writing? I can’t put a precise stamp on it. I’ve always had the creative impulse. The one consistent thread throughout my life. 

Do I love it or enjoy it? No, not necessarily. At times, I hate it. But I can’t NOT do it. I feel compelled to create.

And if you are reading this, maybe you feel the same.

Maybe you’ve experienced the rare creative ecstasy that comes with completing a novel, painting, poem, film, sculpture or song, and that more common discouragement when it seems everything appears to be working against you.

After all, it is easy for the artistic mandate to get perverted. Artists, for the most part, hold a low position, at least in American society. “Art” is such a commonly derided term in its true sense (THINK terms like “artsy-fartsy” or someone being excoriated for having “artistic pretensions”) but it is also an overused term. This or that can be “art”. There are terms like “martial arts” to describe (mostly) Asian fighting styles (a word invented for English—it is not used in Asian languages). 

There’s the “art of” this or the “art of” that. There’s no shortage of marketing or motivational books encouraging you to practice “your art” whether it be advertising or animal husbandry. 

The word “art” is so overused, that it makes the definition of “art” incredibly murky.

And I’m not here to answer that question. Many others have done or attempted to define art. Leo Tolstoy himself wrote a book tract entitled What is Art? He can confidently answer the question better than I can. I’ll just say, there is certainly an art to doing many tasks, where doing something well (whether it be cleaning your house, making a cup of coffee, having a conversation etc.), though probably transient, can cause an at times a transcendent sense of fulfillment. And I’m not here to demean that in any way. I’m talking creative arts as vocation—even if part-time. I can’t put my finger on it, but I know this type of art when I see it.

However, I can confidently say, if you are an advertising executive or work in some corporate, mercantile field other than the arts, and you are reading this to improve at your respective profession, like some read books on creativity to help them get ahead in their careers…this book is not for you.

But if you are in a corporate or business field, or working any old job, just trying to make ends meet, provide for your family, but are an artist outside your current employment, then by all means, continue. I sympathize. I haven’t BEEN there. I am there.

So maybe that’s why I feel the compulsion to write this?

Maybe I, above all, need to read it.

But the reason doesn’t matter.

I write because I have to.


TROY FRANCIS THE DAGESTANI DIVA

  TROY FRANCIS THE DAGESTANI DIVA   I knew very little about Dagestan before meeting Safia and to be honest I don’t know a great deal more n...